Skip to main content

"A Discovery Of Witches" by Deborah Harkness

 A Discovery of Witches by Deborah Harkness

 Finicky Fyction Book Reviewer Rating: ***/* 3.5 Stars ***/*

It’s a good story in general, and there were times when I couldn’t put the book down!

 

*This review contains no spoilers.  

 

Diana Bishop is a witch.

 

However, she’s not just your everyday, run-of-the-mill, all-gothed-up and brewing potions type of witch.

 

If you were traipsing through the corridors of Oxford College in England, Diana Bishop wouldn’t look any different from the faculty, staff, and students going about their day.

 

And whether Diana likes it or not – and she really does not like i, at first – she is a very different type of witch, indeed.

 

It isn’t long until Diana finds herself digging into her past, a past that was supposedly buried along with her parents after they were killed in a car crash. This chapter in Diana’s life begins when Ashmole 872 – an ancient text on alchemy, which is said to hold the key to the creation of witches, vampires, and other such creatures – goes missing from Oxford’s Bodleian Library.

 

In a desperate attempt to find the book (which is a Pandora’s Box for others like Diana if it falls into the wrong hands), Diana struggles to keep her prying (but loving) aunts at bay…

…all while also trying to not fall in love with a handsome, scholarly vampire named Matthew Clairmont.

 

Matthew wants – and tries so hard – to bring Diana out of her comfort zone. Eventually he insists she travels with him to his chateau in France, as a means to keep her safe from the many enemies that exist between the pair. It is here that Diana learns to let go of routine and enjoy the finer things in life; however, her escape from the norm doesn’t come without its dangers.

 

Will Matthew be able to protect the first woman he’s fallen in love with since his wife died? Will Diana learn to embrace her past – AND her love - all while attempting to find and return Ashmole 872 to the Bodliean?

 

AND!

 

Will Diana and Matthew be able to come together to prevent a war from breaking out among the other creatures while keeping humans from learning their truth?  

 

Overall, I did really enjoy the first book in the All Souls Trilogy, written by Deborah Harkness. She manages to blend magic and science together seamlessly, and presents it in a way that science is magic and without magic, there wouldn’t be science.

 

As one friend of mine has said about the book, it’s “a dense read”. I myself consider it a slow burn; not as much as A Game of Thrones by George R.R. Martin, but the academic aspect can be a lot to take in if one isn’t scientifically inclined. With that being said, this isn’t the type of book to be read in one sitting. If you’re a fast reader, maybe…but it’s certainly more enjoyable if you take your time with it, imo.

 

I chose this book to review for the month of February because of Valentine’s Day, and with the complications of Diana and Matthew’s relationship, I feel the two are very relatable as far as how they handle the struggles of protecting one another while putting their own lives on the line…while trying to protect the lives of those closest to them, all in the name of love.

 

Personally my favorite moments throughout the novel were the interactions between Diana and Ysbeau, Matthew’s mother. She is a force to be reckoned with, and when the ancient female vampire shares the same room with a modern witch, who has a hefty ancestry of her own (the Bishops can be traced back to the Salem Witch Trials – true story!), shenanigans ensue.

 

Have you read the All Souls Trilogy? Did you read past the first title, A Discovery of Witches? What are your overall thoughts? Let’s chat about it in the comments!

 

Until next time, my friend…

 

Happy Reading!

 

~Melanie

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

"The Two Lost Mountains" by Matthew Reilly - Review Contributed by Melanie Delaney

This review contains no spoilers or trigger warnings. Thank you so much for contributing your review, Melanie! *smiles*  -Melanie FINICKY FYCTION STAR RATING SYSTEM * Ugh. I just cannot with this book! ** Oy – not a fan. DNF’d before page 50. *** It’s a good story in general. **** Great read – highly recommend! ***** OMG I LOVE THIS BOOK SO MUCH I WANT TO LIVE IN IT!    Another stellar installment by the master of high-octane action-adventure. *No Spoilers The Two Lost Mountains is the 6 th book in the Jack West series. The novels are a cross between Indiana Jones and Jason Bourne, complete with ancient treasures and conspiracies all rolled into one. The scope and grandeur of the settings are phenomenal and the clever way legends, ancient cultures, and buildings are woven together make me sit back and marvel at the level of research it must take to make it all believable. You need to strap yourself in when you read any Matthew Reilly book, and this one is no exception. J

Why I've DNF'd **2** Books in January

  FINICKY FYCTION STAR RATING SYSTEM * Ugh. I just cannot with this book! ** Oy – not a fan. DNF’d before page 50. *** It’s a good story in general. **** Great read – highly recommend! ***** OMG I LOVE THIS BOOK SO MUCH I WANT TO LIVE IN IT!    *sigh*   I hate to start a new post off this way, but I have to be honest. I have two titles that I Did Not Finish (DNF) this month, and I’m quite disappointed that these particular titles were added to that category of my Read books for 2021. What are those two books, you ask? The first is The Lake House by Kate Morton, and the second is The Art of Racing in the Rain by Garth Stein. I’ll try not to be too long-winded, but I also won’t tip-toe around my reasonings for adding these titles to my DNF list. A shared complaint for both works is the amount of factual information that is included within the narratives. Now, don’t get me wrong: I’m totally okay with true facts being included in fiction. HOWEVER, I don’t wa